Skip to content

Julian's Dictionary of Hymnology · Vol. I, p. 433, col. i

God moves in a mysterious way

W. Cowper

In The Hymnal 1982

God moves in a mysterious way. W. Cowper. [Providence.] The commonly accepted history of this hymn is that it was composed by Cowper in 1773, after an attempt to commit suicide by drowning in the Ouse at Olney. In the Memoirs of Cowper by Hayley, and by Southey, as also in that of J. Newton, by Bull, there are painful details of his insanity in 1773. In Southey there is a distinct statement to the effect that his mania was suicidal, and that he made an attempt upon his life in October, 1773. Southey says (1853, vol. i. p. 174):- " In the new character which his delirium had assumed [that it was the will of God that he should put an end to his life] the same perfect spirit of submission was manifested. Mr. Newton says 'Even that attempt he made in October was a proof of it ; for it was solely owing to the power the enemy had of impressing upon his disturbed imagination that it was the will of God he should, after the example of Abraham, perform an expensive act of obedience, and offer, not a son, but himself.' " (May 26, 1774.)

This is conclusive as to the intended suicide ; but there is no indication in the Memoirs that after his attack he wrote anything whatever until about April, 1774. Of this period Southey says : —

" His mind, though possessed by its fatal delusion, had recovered in some degree its activity, and in some of his most melancholy moments he used to compose lines descriptive of his own unhappy state." (1853, vol. i. p. 177.)

To our mind it is evident that Cowper must have written this hymn, either early in 1773, before his insanity became so intense as to lead him to attempt suicide in the October of that year, or else in April of 1774, when " he used to compose lines descriptive of his own unhappy state." Of these dates the latter is the more probable of the two, but neither will agree with the popular account of the origin of the hymn. Its publication agrees with this date, as it appeared in J. Newton's Twenty-six Letters on Religious Subjects; to which are added Hymns, &c., by Omicron, London, 1774. The actual date is fixed by Newton. He says : —

" Thursday, July 6th [1774]. Omicron's Letters are now published. May the Lord accompany them with His blessing. In reading them I could not but observe how different I appear on paper from what I know myself to be," &c.

In Omicron's Letters it is in 6 st. of 4 l., is entitled " Light shining out of Darkness," and is unsigned. It also appeared in the July number of the Gospel Magazine for 1774 (p. 307), in the same form and with the same title ; but in this instance it is signed " J. W." We find it also in R. Conyers's Coll. of Ps. & Hymns of the same year, in the same form and with the same title, but without signature. It appears again in the Gospel Magazine, Dec., 1777, p. 555, at the end of a letter " On Affliction." This letter is unsigned. At the close of the hymn these words are added : —

" By Miss Ussington, late of Islington, who died in May, 1776. Taken from the original."

In this case the st. ii. is omitted ; the eight lines of st. iii. and iv. are rearranged ; a slight change is made in st. vi., and the following is added : —

" When midnight shades are all withdrawn

The opening day shall rise,

Whose ever calm and cloudless morn

Shall know no low'ring skies."

This uncertainty about the authorship of the hymn was set at rest in 1779, when J. Newton gave the original text and title from Omicron's Letters in the Olney Hymns, Bk. iii., No. 15, and signed it "C." From the first it gradually grew in importance and interest, until it has become one of the most widely known hymns in English-speaking countries. It has also been translated into several languages, including Latin, by R. Bingham in his Hymno. Christi. Lati., 1871, as " Secretis miranda viis opera numen " ; and Dr. Macgill in his Songs of the Christian Creed and Life, 1876, as, " Deus mundum, en, molitur." Montgomery's estimate of this hymn is very high. He says of it, "It is a lyric of high tone and character, and rendered awfully interesting by the circumstances under which it was written — in the twilight of departing reason" (The Christian Poet, 1825, Preface). Montgomery evidently thought the hymn was composed before the sad breakdown of 1773. [J. J.]